Colonial Stamp & Coin Co

Colonial Stamp & Coin Co

Located in Kingston, this esteemed coin dealer specializes in providing a vast selection of rare and collectible coins. With a commitment to authenticity and customer service, they have built a reputation for being a trusted source among collectors and enthusiasts alike. The knowledgeable staff is always ready to assist, offering expert advice and insights that cater to both novice and seasoned collectors.

Their welcoming environment makes it easy for visitors to explore a diverse inventory, including historic coins and unique collectibles. Open only a few days a week, the business ensures personalized attention, allowing customers to receive dedicated service during their visits. Whether you are looking to buy, sell, or appraise coins, this Kingston establishment is dedicated to making each transaction a rewarding experience.

• Opposite Herzog’s Lumber Yard, Willow Park Office Complex, 656 Aaron Ct, Kingston, NY 12401, United States
• (845) 336-5390

Latest Feedback

"I had a fantastic experience here! The staff was incredibly knowledgeable and took the time to explain the history behind the coins I was interested in. I walked away with some amazing finds and a deeper appreciation for coin collecting. Highly recommend this place to anyone looking to expand their collection!"

"What a hidden gem! I visited recently to sell some coins from my grandfather's estate, and the team was so respectful and professional. They provided a fair appraisal and made the entire process smooth and easy. I left feeling valued as a customer and would definitely return for future needs."

"As a lifelong collector, I've visited many coin dealers, but this one stands out for its exceptional customer service. The staff not only helped me find some rare pieces but also shared valuable tips on maintaining my collection. It's refreshing to see such passion and dedication in this field. I'll definitely be back!"

Customer Reviews

What People Say

Evander Ashford

★★★★★

July 17, 2024

I had an incredible experience at this coin dealer! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by the staff, who were eager to help. I recently inherited a family collection and was feeling overwhelmed by the sheer number of coins. The team here went above and beyond to assist me. They patiently guided me through the process, explaining the significance of various coins and helping me determine their worth. What impressed me most was their transparency; they didn’t rush me into making any decisions. It was clear they genuinely cared about my interests. The store is clean, well-organized, and has a wide array of collectibles. I especially loved the section dedicated to historical coins; it felt like stepping into a small museum! In terms of pricing, I found their offers to be reasonable, and I appreciated their willingness to negotiate fairly. My only suggestion would be to expand their business hours; even a few extra hours on Saturdays could help accommodate more customers. Nonetheless, I left feeling satisfied and excited to dive deeper into my collection. I will definitely be recommending this place to my friends and family who share my passion for coins. Overall, a five-star experience!

👍 3 👎 0

Colton Baron

★★★★★

April 21, 2024

As someone who has been collecting coins for years, my experience here was nothing short of fantastic! The staff was incredibly knowledgeable and truly passionate about coins. I brought in a few pieces from my collection that I was unsure about, and they took the time to examine each one carefully, providing me with detailed information on their history and value. I was pleasantly surprised by their honesty; they could have easily offered me a higher price for some coins, but they advised me to hold onto them for a while longer, indicating they might increase in value. The shop itself has a great selection, with everything from vintage pieces to more modern coins. The atmosphere was inviting, and I felt comfortable asking questions. My only slight issue was the limited hours; I wish they were open on weekends, as it can be tough to visit during the week. Overall, I left feeling more informed and excited about my collection. I can’t recommend this place enough for anyone interested in numismatics or just looking to add something special to their collection. I’ll definitely be returning to explore more and see what new items they have in stock!

👍 4 👎 1