Innersleeve Records

Innersleeve Records

Located in the charming town of Amagansett, this record store is a haven for music lovers and collectors alike. With a diverse selection of vinyl records spanning various genres, the store offers an impressive inventory that caters to both vintage enthusiasts and contemporary fans. The knowledgeable staff is always on hand to provide personalized recommendations, ensuring that every visit is a memorable experience.

Additionally, the store hosts regular events, including live music performances and listening parties, creating a vibrant community atmosphere. Whether you're searching for a rare find or simply want to explore new sounds, this record store stands out as a unique destination that celebrates the love of music.

• 199 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930, United States
• (631) 604-6248

Latest Feedback

"I absolutely love this place! Every time I visit, I discover something new. The staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, making recommendations that are spot on. I found a rare vinyl I've been searching for ages, and the atmosphere is just perfect for browsing. It's definitely my go-to spot for all things music!"

"What a gem! I stumbled upon this record store while exploring Amagansett and was blown away by the variety of records available. They have everything from classic rock to indie artists. Plus, the layout is cozy and inviting. I spent hours just flipping through albums and chatting with the staff. I can't wait to come back for their next live music event!"

"As a long-time vinyl collector, I can confidently say this store is one of the best I've been to. They have an incredible selection, and I love that they feature local artists too. The staff genuinely cares about music and it shows in their recommendations. I walked out with a couple of amazing finds and a big smile on my face. Highly recommend for anyone who loves records!"

Customer Reviews

What People Say

Dominic Walker

★★★★★

June 11, 2025

What a gem of a place! I stumbled upon this record store while exploring the area and I’m so glad I did. The vibe is incredibly chill, and the layout is really easy to navigate. I was pleasantly surprised by the variety they have, from classic rock to indie and everything in between. I found a couple of albums that were hard to track down elsewhere, and they even had a section for local artists! The staff was super friendly and knowledgeable, ready to share their recommendations. I will say, the checkout line was a bit long, but it was totally worth the wait. I left with a huge smile on my face and a couple of new favorites in hand. Definitely coming back soon!

👍 5 👎 0

Dominic Harrington

★★★★★

April 14, 2024

I recently visited this record store and it was such a delightful experience! The moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile from the staff, who are clearly passionate about music. The selection is impressive; I found some rare vinyl that I had been searching for ages! I especially loved how they have listening stations set up, allowing you to preview albums before buying, which is such a fantastic idea. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for browsing through records. The only minor issue I encountered was that the store felt a bit cramped during peak hours, making it slightly difficult to maneuver. But honestly, it’s a small price to pay for such a great selection. I ended up spending way more time there than I intended to, and I can't wait to go back next weekend to explore more. Highly recommend it for any music lover!

👍 7 👎 0

Sakura Jackson

★★★★★

March 3, 2024

As a long-time vinyl collector, I often visit record stores in different cities, and I have to say, this one really stands out! From the moment I entered, the charming decor and the vintage posters set a nostalgic tone. The staff here is not only friendly but also genuinely enthusiastic about music. They took the time to chat with me about my favorite genres and even suggested some new artists I hadn't heard of before. The selection is diverse, catering to both the mainstream and the obscure, which I absolutely loved. I stumbled upon some limited editions that I never thought I'd find. The only thing I would suggest is to have a few more listening stations, as it was a bit crowded when I was there. However, this didn’t take away from the overall experience. I left with a stack of records and a renewed excitement for my collection! I can’t recommend this place enough for anyone looking to explore or expand their music taste.

👍 5 👎 0