Mustang Sally's

Mustang Sally's

This Bay Shore bar and grill offers an exceptional dining experience, combining culinary artistry with a vibrant atmosphere.
Patrons can indulge in a diverse menu that features gourmet burgers, artisanal pizzas, and an extensive selection of craft beers.
With a focus on high-quality ingredients and innovative recipes, this establishment sets the standard for upscale casual dining. Its inviting ambiance is perfect for both social gatherings and corporate events, making it a premier choice for those seeking a memorable culinary adventure. Guests appreciate the attentive service and attention to detail, ensuring every visit is both enjoyable and satisfying.

• 186 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
• +1 631-665-9822

Latest Feedback

"The culinary experience here is outstanding; the gourmet burgers are a must-try and the atmosphere is perfect for gatherings."

"I was impressed by the quality of the food and the extensive craft beer selection. It's a great spot for a casual night out!"

"Exceptional service and a diverse menu make this bar and grill a top choice for both leisure and business events."

Customer Reviews

What People Say

Percival Russo

★★★★★

August 14, 2025

I recently visited this bar & grill and was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere! The rustic decor really sets the mood, and it was a perfect spot to catch up with friends. I ordered the BBQ ribs, and they were absolutely delicious—fall-off-the-bone tender with just the right amount of sauce. The staff was friendly and attentive, which made the experience even better. My only small critique would be that the wait for our food was a bit longer than expected, but it was definitely worth it. Overall, a great place to unwind and enjoy some hearty food. I’ll be back for sure!

👍 2 👎 1

Karen Draper

★★★★★

November 26, 2024

What a gem of a place! I went here on a whim after hearing great things, and it did not disappoint. The vibe is super laid-back, making it a perfect gathering spot. I particularly loved the live music they had that night; it really added to the whole experience! I tried their signature burger, and it was juicy with a perfect char. The homemade fries were crispy and seasoned just right—definitely a highlight! The drink menu is impressive too; I tried a local craft beer that paired wonderfully with my meal. One small thing I noticed was that the seating could get a bit cramped during busy hours, but it never felt overwhelming. Overall, I had a fantastic evening filled with good food and great company. I’m already planning my next visit!

👍 5 👎 2